Criminal and foreign-intelligence surveillance

CYBER ESPIONAGE AND ELECTRONIC SURVEILLANCE:
BEYOND THE MEDIA COVERAGE
William C. Banks∗
INTRODUCTION
In the twenty-first century it seems that everyone is eavesdropping on
everyone else—governments and companies, militaries, law enforcement and
intelligence agencies, hackers, criminals, and terrorists. State-sponsored and
private cyber espionage and criminal and foreign-intelligence surveillance
have ramped up in part because the national security threat environment is ever
more complicated and multifaceted, and the ability to meet it is increasingly
dependent on good intelligence, in real time. However, surveillance and
espionage have also increased because the Internet and cyber technology so
readily enable exploitation of intellectual property and other commercially
valuable information. Among its many attributes, the Internet has introduced
new dynamics to the age-old tensions between security and liberty. The
Internet expands our freedom to communicate at the same time it makes us less
secure. It expands our online vulnerabilities while it lowers the visibility of
intrusions. The Internet provides new means for enabling privacy intrusions
and causing national security and economic harm even as it provides
governments with ever more sophisticated tools to keep tabs on bad actors. Yet
in the cat and mouse game between the government agents and suspected
terrorists and criminals, ever newer devices and encryption programs ratchet
up privacy protections in ways that may prevent government access to those
devices and their contents. These devices and programs, in turn, may enable
cyber theft or even destructive terrorist attacks.
Espionage and intelligence collection are part of the national security
apparatus of every state. Cyber espionage involves deliberate activities to
penetrate computer systems or networks used by an adversary for obtaining
information resident on or transiting through these systems or networks. A
pertinent subset is economic espionage, where a state attempts to acquire
secrets held by foreign companies. Of course, states conducted economic
∗ Board of Advisers Distinguished Professor, Syracuse University College of Law; Director, Institute for
National Security and Counterterrorism.
514 EMORY LAW JOURNAL [Vol. 66:513
espionage before the Internet, but the availability of cyber exploitation rapidly
and significantly expanded the activity.1
Electronic surveillance intercepts communications between two or more
parties. The intercepts can give insight into what is said, planned, and
anticipated by adversaries. Because such vast quantities of communications
now travel through the Internet, more than humans can comprehend in their
raw form, surveillance often leads to processing and exploitation through
algorithms or other search methods that can query large amounts of collected
data in pursuit of more specific intelligence objectives.2
Traditional state-sponsored surveillance and espionage have been
transformed into high-tech and high-stakes enterprises. Some of the cyber
activity is electronic surveillance for foreign intelligence purposes, mimics
traditional spying, and services a range of what most of us would concede are
legitimate national security objectives—anticipating terrorist attacks, learning
about the foreign policy plans of adversaries, and gaining advantage in foreign
relations negotiations.3
However, a good deal of the cyber sleuthing involves
economic matters, sometimes extending to include intellectual property theft,
and is undertaken by states or their proxies to secure comparative economic
advantage in trade negotiations, other deals, or for particular companies.4
I. ECONOMIC CYBER ESPIONAGE
Governments and their agents have been exploiting Internet connectivity by
penetrating the electronic networks of foreign companies for nearly a quartercentury.5
Until 2010, companies chose to ignore the problem, more or less.6
Then Google publicly claimed that China had stolen source code and used it to
1 Gerald O’Hara, Cyber-Espionage: A Growing Threat to the American Economy, 19 COMMLAW
CONSPECTUS: J. COMM. L. & POL’Y 241, 241–42 (2010). 2 See Joe Pappalardo, NSA Data Mining: How It Works, POPULAR MECHANICS (Sept. 11, 2013), http://
www.popularmechanics.com/military/a9465/nsa-data-mining-how-it-works-15910146/. 3 Heather Kelly, NSA Chief: Snooping Is Crucial to Fighting Terrorism, CNN (Aug. 1, 2013, 10:35
AM), http://www.cnn.com/2013/07/31/tech/web/nsa-alexander-black-hat/; David E. Sanger, U.S. Cyberattacks
Target ISIS in a New Line of Combat, N.Y. TIMES (Apr. 24, 2016), http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/25/us/
politics/us-directs-cyberweapons-at-isis-for-first-time.html. 4 See infra notes 5–9 and accompanying text. 5 Joel Brenner, The New Industrial Espionage, 10 AM. INT., Winter 2015, at 28, 28–29, http://www.theamerican-interest.com/2014/12/10/the-new-industrial-espionage/. 6 Id. at 29.
2017] CYBER ESPIONAGE AND ELECTRONIC SURVEILLANCE 515
spy and to penetrate other companies’ networks.7
At about the same time,
major economic espionage was carried out against large western oil companies
and traced to a site in China, and another theft lifted security key tokens, which
in turn led to the penetration of other firms, including defense contractors in
the United States.8
In May of 2014, the FBI issued “Most Wanted” posters for five Chinese
nationals, members of the Peoples’ Liberation Army.9
In United States v.
Wang, the five were indicted by a federal grand jury for breaking into
computer systems of American companies and stealing trade secrets for the
benefit of Chinese companies.10 Although there was no chance that the United
States would obtain jurisdiction over the accused so that they could be tried,
the indictments may have been intended to incentivize negotiations with the
Chinese on corporate spying. At first, the Chinese responded by complaining
about U.S. hypocrisy and double standards.11 The Chinese asserted that
American authorities have conducted large-scale, organized cyber-espionage
activities against government officials, companies, and individuals, in China
and many other states.12 The distinction that our government draws between
spying for national security purposes and not spying on companies to give a
competitive edge to one’s own businesses is not recognized as valid by China,
and they point out that our definition of national security includes obtaining
advantages in trade negotiations and for other international economic purposes,
including enforcing sanctions regimes and detecting bribery.13
Then, in 2015, some seemingly remarkable things happened. Following the
indictment of the Chinese hackers and an executive order promulgated by
President Barack Obama that authorized sanctions against malicious hackers,14
7 Andrew Jacobs & Miguel Helft, Google, Citing Attack, Threatens to Exit China, N.Y. TIMES (Jan. 12,
2010), http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/13/world/asia/13beijing.html. 8 Nathan Hodge & Adam Entous, Oil Firms Hit by Hackers from China, Report Says, WALL ST. J. (Feb.
10, 2011, 12:01 AM), http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748703716904576134661111518864;
Elinor Mills, China Linked to New Breaches Tied to RSA, CNET (June 6, 2011, 4:00 AM), https://www.cnet.
com/news/china-linked-to-new-breaches-tied-to-rsa/. 9 Cyber’s Most Wanted, FBI, https://www.fbi.gov/wanted/cyber (last visited Apr. 25, 2016). 10 Indictment, United States v. Wang, Criminal No. 14-118 (W.D. Pa. May 1, 2014), https://www.justice.
gov/iso/opa/resources/5122014519132358461949.pdf. 11 Jonathan Kaiman, China Reacts Furiously to US Cyber-Espionage Charges, GUARDIAN (May 20,
2014, 8:31 AM), https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/may/20/china-reacts-furiously-us-cyber-espionagecharges. 12 David E. Sanger, With Spy Charges, U.S. Draws a Line that Few Others Recognize, N.Y. TIMES (May
19, 2014), http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/20/us/us-treads-fine-line-in-fighting-chinese-espionage.html. 13 Id. 14 Exec. Order No. 13,694, 80 Fed. Reg. 18,077 (Apr. 2, 2015).
516 EMORY LAW JOURNAL [Vol. 66:513
the United States and China reached an agreement on a range of cybersecurity
matters.15 In addition to cooperation on law enforcement matters in
cyberspace, China reversed its prominent policy position and committed not to
engage in commercially-motivated cyber espionage.16 The agreement also
includes implementation and compliance provisions, the violation of which
could lead to sanctions under the Obama administration executive order.17
Although the 2014 indictments had been dismissed as meaningless by
many, the Chinese appear not to have understood their lack of practical
significance and instead viewed them more like sanctions.18 The PLA unit also
may have felt exposed and diminished in its prestige after the indictments.19
Meanwhile, news reports indicate that China began to dismantle its economic
espionage network and started to crack down on PLA hackers who were
moonlighting on the side and selling information to Chinese companies that
was not central to the PLA national security mission.20 A few weeks after the
U.S.–China agreement was reached, similar agreements were reached between
China and the United Kingdom and China and Germany.21
II. SURVEILLANCE
Meanwhile, governments are not the only participants in the cybersleuthing. The Islamic State (ISIS) has broadened its recruitment and appeal,
focusing in part on young, tech-savvy persons living far from the battlefields of
Syria and Iraq.22 In October 2015, the United States arrested Kosovar Ardit
Ferizi while he was living in Malaysia and charged him with providing
15 JOHN W. ROLLINS, CONG. RESEARCH SERV., IN10376, U.S.-CHINA CYBER AGREEMENT (2015),
https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/IN10376.pdf. 16 Id. 17 Id. 18 Ellen Nakashima, Following U.S. Indictments, China Shifts Commercial Hacking Away from Military
to Civilian Agency, WASH. POST (Nov. 30, 2015), https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/nationalsecurity/following-us-indictments-chinese-military-scaled-back-hacks-on-american-industry/2015/11/30/fcdb
097a-9450-11e5-b5e4-279b4501e8a6_story.html. 19 Id. 20 Id. 21 Rowena Mason, Xi Jinping State Visit: UK and China Sign Cybersecurity Pact, GUARDIAN (Oct. 21,
2015, 12:13 PM), http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2015/oct/21/uk-china-cybersecurity-pact-xi-jinpingdavid-cameron; Stefan Nicola, China Working to Halt Commercial Cyberwar in Deal with Germany,
BLOOMBERG TECH. (Oct. 29, 2015, 8:31 AM), http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-10-29/chinaworking-to-halt-commercial-cyberwar-in-deal-with-germany. 22 Maeghin Alarid, Recruitment and Radicalization: The Role of Social Media and New Technology, in
IMPUNITY: COUNTERING ILLICIT POWER IN WAR AND TRANSITION 313, 322 (Michelle Hughes & Michael
Miklaucic eds., 2016).
2017] CYBER ESPIONAGE AND ELECTRONIC SURVEILLANCE 517
material support to terrorism by hacking a U.S. government database and
stealing personal information on more than 1350 military and civilian
government personnel.23 Ferizi allegedly passed the information to an
operative of ISIS.24
The ISIS Cyber Caliphate hacking unit seized control of U.S. Central
Command Twitter and YouTube feeds early in 2015, using them to post
propaganda videos and personal information on top military officials.25 The
hackers seized more than 54,000 Twitter accounts for the same objectives
again late in 2015.26 Even terrorists who seek visible, kinetic effects from their
attacks—and are thus less likely to engage in malware insertion and other
disruptive, but not destructive, cyber attacks—increasingly rely on digital
protections (encryption) to assure the secrecy of their communications.27 Most
notably, ISIS has demonstrated a sophisticated understanding of methods for
shielding its communications from electronic surveillance by intelligence
agencies. Security companies have described a manual released by an ISIS
operative urging its followers to use fake phone numbers to set up an encrypted
chat system that will shield ISIS communications from intelligence
surveillance and avoid revealing personal information.28
For the most part, international law has been a bystander to this entire
fabric of stealth, deception, and greed. The individual strands of this story are
bound together by a unique set of oppositional forces and compelling needs for
action.
• The costs of economic cyber espionage are staggeringly high and
will continue to rise unless something is done.29
23 Joe Davidson, ISIS Threatens Feds, Military After Theft of Personal Data, WASH. POST (Jan. 31,
2016), https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/federal-eye/wp/2016/01/31/isis-threatens-feds-military-aftertheft-of-personal-data/. 24 Id. 25 CNN Staff, CENTCOM Twitter Account Hacked, Suspended, CNN POLITICS (Jan. 12, 2015, 5:43 PM),
http://www.cnn.com/2015/01/12/politics/centcom-twitter-hacked-suspended/. 26 Jigmey Bhutia, Isis ‘Cyber Caliphate’ Hacks More than 54,000 Twitter Accounts, INT’L BUS. TIMES
(Nov. 9, 2015, 9:10 AM), http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/isis-cyber-caliphate-hacks-more-54000-twitter-accounts1527821. 27 Kate O’Keeffe, American ISIS Recruits Down, but Encryption Is Helping Terrorists’ Online Efforts,
Says FBI Director, WALL ST. J. (May 11, 2016, 8:54 PM), http://www.wsj.com/articles/american-isis-recruitsdown-but-encryption-is-helping-terrorists-online-efforts-says-fbi-director-1463007527?mg=id-wsj. 28 Kim Zetter, Security Manual Reveals the OPSEC Advice ISIS Gives Recruits, WIRED (Nov. 19, 2015,
4:45 PM), http://www.wired.com/2015/11/isis-opsec-encryption-manuals-reveal-terrorist-group-security-protocols/. 29 See infra note 53 and accompanying text.
518 EMORY LAW JOURNAL [Vol. 66:513
• The Snowden leaks have sewn distrust among citizens and
between allied governments, each doubting the veracity of the
United States and other nations’ intelligence collection
practices.30
• Intelligence collection incidentally but persistently invades
citizens’ liberties in collecting beyond the reasonable needs of
government.31
• Yet continuing terrorist attacks in a wide range of locations
reinforces the need for the most effective means of electronic
surveillance of potential terrorist activities.32
• Traditional espionage is now scapegoated in ways that harm
allied relationships and impose costs on intelligence collection.
If we do not act to put a stopper in these escalating crises of costs and
confidence soon, the security and integrity of the Internet may be up for grabs.
Not to mention the efficacy of intelligence collection by electronic means.
III. THE LIMITED ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL LAW
Cyberspace remains a netherworld for intelligence activities—whatever
surveillance or cyber spying a government does outside its own national
borders is, in most circumstances, an international law free-for-all. Decades of
state practice tell us that surveillance or espionage may be conducted across
borders without violating sovereignty.33 Examples of presumably permissible
behavior include collecting the contents of electronic communications or
metadata about them; watching government computer systems, including
SCADA systems, through cyber penetration; exfiltration of government data,
including military or other national security secrets; and denial of service
penetrations that decrease the bandwidth for government web sites. Disruptive
cyber activities that are not destructive or coercive in some way apparently do
not violate international law. The line between permitted espionage and
unlawful cyber intrusions is far from clear.
30 Alan Travis, Snowden Leak: Governments’ Hostile Reaction Fuelled Public’s Distrust of Spies,
GUARDIAN (June 15, 2015, 11:19 AM), https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jun/15/snowden-files-us-ukgovernment-hostile-reaction-distrust-spies. 31 See infra notes 45–49 and accompanying text. 32 See Kelly, supra note 3; Sanger, supra note 3. 33 Glenn Sulmasy & John Yoo, Counterintuitive: Intelligence Operations and International Law, 28
MICH. J. INT’L L. 625, 626, 628 (2007).
2017] CYBER ESPIONAGE AND ELECTRONIC SURVEILLANCE 519
One response to the increasing concerns about online theft of intellectual
property and complaints of invasions of privacy has been for more
governments around the world to enact or at least talk about data-localization
laws. Such laws, already in place in authoritarian states such as Russia, China,
and Iran, typically enforce limitations for all citizen data and the infrastructure
that supports it.34 China strictly vets companies selling Internet technology and
services in China.35 Now-democratic states such as Brazil, India, and Germany
are contemplating data-localization. Brazil plans to stop using Microsoft
Outlook for e-mail, and Germany has unhooked from Verizon and signed on
with Deutsche Telekom.36 There is talk among our European allies about
creating a European Internet.37
To what extent does the uniqueness of the cyber domain make cyber
espionage and foreign intelligence surveillance legally distinct? On the one
hand, the fact that no person has to cross a border to accomplish the espionage
or surveillance probably does not matter, legally. Remoteness is just a means
of collection. On the other hand, attribution, knowing who stole your secrets, is
a serious technical problem and makes controlling cyber exploitation more
difficult than keeping tabs on traditional spying. In addition, in the cyber world
distinguishing exploitation from a cyber attack (an intrusion designed to
disrupt or destroy systems or data) can be difficult. The malware that exploits a
computer to retrieve its data may be indistinguishable at first from malware
that will destroy the computer hard drive. Thus, the exploited state may be
hard-pressed deciding how to prepare and respond.
States have historically tolerated traditional espionage because they all do it
and gain from it.38 Domestic laws proscribe spying for those that are caught.
Most espionage disputes are resolved through diplomacy, and in extreme
cases, states send the spies home. In cyber espionage, the status quo favors
34 Anupam Chander & Uyên P. Lê, Data Nationalism, 64 EMORY L.J. 677, 686–88, 701–02, 735–36
(2015). 35 Paul Mozur, New Rules in China Upset Western Tech Companies, N.Y. TIMES (Jan. 28, 2015),
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/29/technology/in-china-new-cybersecurity-rules-perturb-western-techcompanies.html?_r=0. 36 Anton Troianovski & Danny Yadron, German Government Ends Verizon Contract, WALL ST. J. (June
26, 2014, 2:54 PM), http://www.wsj.com/articles/german-government-ends-verizon-contract-1403802226; see
also Brazil to Create Its Own Email System After Protesting U.S. Spying, UPI.COM (Oct. 14, 2013, 5:12 PM),
http://www.upi.com/Science_News/Technology/2013/10/14/Brazil-to-create-its-own-email-system-afterprotesting-US-spying/69911381785172/. 37 Sam Ball, Plans to Stop US Spying with European Internet, FRANCE 24, http://www.france24.com/en/
20140217-european-internet-plans-nsa-spying (last updated Feb. 18, 2014). 38 See Sulmasy & Yoo, supra note 33, at 626–29.
520 EMORY LAW JOURNAL [Vol. 66:513
sophisticated countries with the finances and technological capabilities to
extract the intelligence. But the status quo is changing rapidly. Cyberspace
reduces the power differentials among actors. Powerful states have more cyber
resources but also more government and private-sector vulnerabilities. The
advantage increasingly lies with state-sponsored and non-state hackers—the
offense, not the defense—and the costs of cyber exploitation of security and
proprietary data are forcing states to look for ways to curb the espionage.
To date, efforts to anchor the law of cyber espionage or foreign-intelligence
surveillance in international law have developed in three mostly nascent
directions. One potential pathway is the conventional and customary norm of
nonintervention, a corollary to state sovereignty. The principle of
nonintervention is reflected in Article 2(4) of the U.N. Charter and its
prohibition of “the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or
political independence of any state.”39 In theory at least, nonintervention is
broader than use of force and the Charter. As the International Court of Justice
stated in Nicaragua v. United States,
40 wrongful intervention involves
“methods of coercion,”41 and the United States engaged in wrongful
intervention even though it did not use force in Nicaragua. Should
nonintervention take on new meaning in the twenty-first century based on the
expanding cornucopia of technical means for crossing sovereign borders
without human intervention? Apart from the technical means, does the
contemporary use of state-supported espionage to steal trade secrets and
intellectual property constitute intervention? Is a breach of the norm measured
by the impact of the intervention, whether virtual or physical? Certainly cyber
surveillance or espionage targeting government activities interferes with the
internal affairs of the victim state.
However, the legislative history of the Charter and later commentary
confirm that “force” in Article 2(4) does not include economic or political
pressure.42 Thus, under the Charter, espionage does not constitute an
internationally wrongful act triggering state responsibility under international
law. (If a state is responsible for an unlawful act, the victim state is entitled to
reparation, and a state may take any responsive actions that neither amount to a
39 U.N. Charter art. 2, ¶ 4.
40 Military and Paramilitary Activities in and Against Nicaragua (Nicar. v. U.S.), Judgment, 1986 I.C.J.
Rep. 14 (June 27). 41 Id. at ¶ 205. 42 Matthew C. Waxman, Cyber-Attacks and the Use of Force: Back to the Future of Article 2(4), 36
YALE J. INT’L L. 421, 422 (2011).
2017] CYBER ESPIONAGE AND ELECTRONIC SURVEILLANCE 521
use of force nor breach a treaty or customary law obligation. Or it may take
countermeasures.)43 Cyber exploitation directed at financial targets, for
example, could cause economic loss, panic in the streets, and a loss of public
confidence in the state. Yet if there is no physical damage or loss of life, the
Charter suggests that the norm of nonintervention has not been violated.
Some scholars have argued in the alternative that cyber espionage is a
lawful precursor to a state’s exercise of its U.N. Charter Article 51 self-defense
rights.44 Preparing for and anticipating an armed attack is critically important
in the modern world, the argument goes. If not affirmatively allowed as an
adjunct to Article 51, others maintain that espionage has been recognized by
widespread state practice and thus is supported by a norm of customary
international law.
From the human rights perspective, electronic surveillance could be seen to
violate the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR),
Article 17(1), which protects against “arbitrary or unlawful interference
with . . . privacy.”45 The reach and application of the ICCPR and a similar
provision in the European Convention on Human Rights46 (ECHR) outside any
state’s territory are unsettled, although there is support for the view that the
protection extends to foreign nationals outside the territory of the state party in
the context of electronic surveillance or cyber intrusions. The U.N. Special
Rapporteur wrote that Article 17 protects against “mass surveillance of the
Internet,” and that bulk surveillance must be justified following a
proportionality analysis that accounts for “systematic interference with the
Internet privacy rights of a potentially unlimited number of innocent people
located in any part of the world.”47 The Rapporteur finds bulk collection
“indiscriminately corrosive of online privacy” and threatening to the core of
Article 17 privacy.48 (Jurisdictional issues cloud whether any court or treaty
body would apply human rights law to surveillance or cyber spying.) Cases are
43 Michael N. Schmitt, “Below the Threshold” Cyber Operations: The Countermeasures Response
Option and International Law, 54 VA. J. INT’L L. 697, 703 (2014). 44 Ashley Deeks, An International Legal Framework for Surveillance, 55 VA. J. INT’L L. 291, 302
(2015); see also U.N. Charter art. 51 (“Nothing in the present Charter shall impair the inherent right of
individual or collective self-defense . . . .”). 45 International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights art. 17, ¶ 1, Dec. 19, 1966, 999 U.N.T.S. 171.
46 Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms art. 8, Nov. 4,
1950, 213 U.N.T.S. 221. 47 U.N. Secretary-General, Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Promotion and Protection of Human
Rights and Fundamental Freedoms While Countering Terrorism, ¶ 59, U.N. Doc. A/69/397 (Sept. 23, 2014). 48 Id.
522 EMORY LAW JOURNAL [Vol. 66:513
pending now in the European Court of Human Rights alleging privacy
violations due to the U.K. Government Communications Headquarters’s
cooperation with the National Security Agency in collecting upstream contents
and bulk data.49
An unusual alignment of interests between some powerful governments
(victims of cyber exploitation and overbroad surveillance), ordinary citizens,
and major corporations and their clients present what may be a propitious time
for forging new international law in these areas. Governments, citizens, and
influential opinion makers learned a great deal about foreign intelligence
surveillance from the Snowden leaks. And the governments most affected by
the Snowden leaks are some of the same ones most victimized by cyber
espionage of one sort or another.
The United States has already begun to limit their surveillance activities in
response to political pressure, not least from the heads of state whose
conversations were recorded.50 Meanwhile, litigation in European and U.S.
courts and a resolution by the U.N. General Assembly addressing the right of
privacy in the digital era51 sow the seeds of a rights-based reorientation of
international law. Perhaps most important, the economic impacts of cyber
espionage and foreign surveillance are considerable. On the surveillance side
of things, Internet service providers and social media companies in the United
States are losing contracts and clients in many places, and the data-localization
laws and other steps taken by some states to insulate “their” piece of the
Internet threaten to further constrain the global economy.52 As for cyber
49 See, e.g., Applicant’s Reply, 10 Human Rights Orgs. v. United Kingdom, App. No. 24960/15 (2016),
https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/3115985-APPLICANTS-REPLY-to-GOVT-OBSERVATIONSPDF.html; Ryan Gallagher, Europe’s Top Human Rights Court Will Consider Legality of Surveillance
Exposed by Edward Snowden, INTERCEPT (Oct. 3, 2016), https://theintercept.com/2016/09/30/echr-nsa-gchqsnowden-surveillance-privacy/. 50 Presidential Policy Directive PPD-28: Directive on Signals Intelligence Activities, 2014 DAILY COMP.
PRES. DOC. 31 (Jan. 17, 2014); REVIEW GROUP ON INTELLIGENCE AND COMMC’NS TECHS., LIBERTY AND
SECURITY IN A CHANGING WORLD: REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE PRESIDENT’S REVIEW GROUP ON
INTELLIGENCE AND COMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLOGIES 20 (2013), https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/
files/docs/2013-12-12_rg_final_report.pdf (suggesting steps to place certain allied leaders’ private
communications off-limits for the NSA). 51 Human Rights Council, Rep. of the Office of the U.N. High Comm’r for Human Rights, The Right to
Privacy in the Digital Age, U.N. Doc. A/HRC/27/37 (June 30, 2014). 52 Claire Cain Miller, Revelations of N.S.A. Spying Cost U.S. Tech Companies, N.Y. TIMES, (Mar. 21,
2014), http://www.nytimes.com/2014/03/22/business/fallout-from-snowden-hurting-bottom-line-of-techcompanies.html.
2017] CYBER ESPIONAGE AND ELECTRONIC SURVEILLANCE 523
espionage, the estimated $300–600 billion annual price tag53 is illustrative of
the costs imposed by theft of IP and trade secrets, along with other valuable
government and private sector information.
States could agree to distinguish national-security espionage from all other
forms, and tolerate only the former. After all, keeping a nation safe is a high
and noble objective, and intelligence can directly serve that end. The trick is to
thoughtfully limit that power to collect intelligence only where it is necessary
to safeguard national-security interests, and then to be sure that the intelligence
function is subject to effective oversight. All other forms of espionage could be
treated as theft, and rules forbidding that activity could be enforced in the
private, commercial realm. It remains difficult in some instances to distinguish
national-security espionage from other spying. Developing customary
international law is a slow, lengthy process, but it could begin in just this way.
If a sufficient number of other states sign on, new international norms may be
made. A similar process could lead to developing international law on
surveillance, perhaps starting with agreements among the Five Eyes—the
English speaking democracies.
Similarly, states could agree that international law forbids spying by a state
for the direct benefit of a private company. Governments can and have at times
established rules of the road for limiting espionage and created incentives for
cooperation. The 2015 U.S.–China agreement is exemplary.54 The new
approaches are necessary because the model response to conventional
espionage—arrest their spies, expel diplomats, and the like—does not work
when the cyber theft is accomplished remotely by unnamed agents. Trade
sanctions, tariffs, and diplomatic pressures are often effective tools.
Another method of influencing international law could be to adapt domestic
laws to international law. Domestic regulation of cyber espionage in the United
States has been provided by the Economic Espionage Act (EEA), which
proscribes the possession, collection, duplication, transfer, or sale of trade
secrets for the benefit of a foreign nation or any of its agents.55 The Justice
Department is expressly given extraterritorial enforcement authority.56
53 Ellen Nakashima & Andrea Peterson, Report: Cybercrime and Espionage Costs $445 Billion Annually,
WASH. POST (June 9, 2014), https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/report-cybercrime-andespionage-costs-445-billion-annually/2014/06/08/8995291c-ecce-11e3-9f5c-9075d5508f0a_story.html (CSIS
places the figure at $375–$575 billion). 54 See supra notes 15–21 and accompanying text. 55 18 U.S.C. § 1831 (2012).
56 18 U.S.C. § 1836 (2012).
524 EMORY LAW JOURNAL [Vol. 66:513
Amendments to the EEA in 2012 and 2013 increased the criminal penalties
and the breadth of coverage for stealing trade secrets to benefit a foreign
government.57 New amendments have been recommended that would provide
a private right of action for those who hold trade secrets that have been subject
to theft.58 In addition, the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA) prohibits
intentionally causing damage through a computer code or program to any
computer connected to the Internet.59 Although not written with espionage in
mind, the CFAA could be used to counter cyber exploitation. These domestic
laws could provide foundational concepts for developing international
agreements and, eventually, international law.
The benefits of augmenting international law with domestically grown
mechanisms are numerous, but ultimately, customary international law needs
an international platform. For example, in the intellectual property realm,
customary international law could incorporate intellectual property theft
proscriptions from the World Trade Organization (WTO) and the related Trade
Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights agreement.60 An advantage is
the use of a respected international forum, where nations such as China could
also seek relief from cyber exploitation (by the United States). A drawback is
that WTO agreements presently require meeting obligations only within the
member’s territory.61 The structure of the agreements could be changed, if they
could figure out how to prove responsibility for a state’s actions outside its
territory.
In an effort to distinguish espionage while applying domestic legal
structures, states could determine that disruptive cyber actions should be
treated differently than espionage. Such agreements could be grafted onto the
Cybercrime Convention.62 The Cybercrime Convention commits states to enact
domestic laws criminalizing cyber theft.63 Of course, the Cybercrime
Convention could be amended to make unlawful espionage that steals trade
secrets or other proprietary information for the benefit of domestic firms. The
domestic laws required by the Convention are largely ineffective against state57 Id.
58 Dennis Crouch, Defend Trade Secret Act Moving Forward, PATENTLY-O (Apr. 5, 2016),
http://patentlyo.com/patent/2016/04/secret-moving-forward.html. 59 18 U.S.C. § 1030 (2012).
60 Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, Apr. 15, 1994, 1869 U.N.T.S.
299. 61 See, e.g., id. art. 1, ¶ 1. 62 Convention on Cybercrime, Nov. 23, 2001, 2296 U.N.T.S. 167.
63 Id. art. 2.
2017] CYBER ESPIONAGE AND ELECTRONIC SURVEILLANCE 525
sponsored theft because of the difficulties of obtaining jurisdiction of accused
cyber criminals and because of diplomatic immunities. The domestic laws are
difficult to enforce anyway because of attribution problems. There are no
enforceable international law violations recognized by the treaty. As it now
stands, the Cybercrime Convention includes no universal definition of
cybercrime, for example.64 Does cybercrime include theft for espionage
purposes? The Convention has demonstrated that problems of cyber espionage
cannot be addressed as a traditional crime problem because a large portion of
what is criminal is state-tolerated or state-supported. Nor are Mutual Legal
Assistance Treaties useful where the crimes are politically motivated and state
sponsored.
Furthermore, distinguishing between cyber espionage and disruptive cyber
activity could encourage states to come to agreements upon some off-limits
parts of cyber. For example, agreements not to disrupt nuclear installations or
other critical infrastructure would be beneficial to all sides. Abolishing spying
on these systems goes hand in hand with limiting disruption. Once the
infrastructure is off-limits for attack, there is no legitimate reason to illicitly
obtain information about that system.
CONCLUSIONS
The confluence of interests between victims of overbroad surveillance and
cyber espionage presents an opportunity to begin developing new norms and
eventual international law that could bring more rationality, predictability, and
privacy protections to the cyber domain. The costs of cyber espionage are real,
and the threats and vulnerabilities will increase with the progression of
technology. Companies and governments are underprepared for the level of
cyber espionage they are facing. Solutions vary, but they all share the common
foundation of increased international cooperation and the development of a
customary international legal framework that everyone understands.
Meanwhile, blowback from the Snowden leaks has generated sufficient
political pressure to cause some changes to surveillance authorities. As those
reforms develop and privacy claims are litigated in international fora and
European courts, it is likely that new international law will emerge, too,
perhaps in tandem with reforms to the limits on cyber espionage.
64 Id. art. 1.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without
permission.

Call us 24/7:
Calculate your essay price
(550 words)

Approximate price: $22

23 k happy customers
9.7 out of 10 satisfaction rate
833 writers active

Real Reviews from our Customers

Academic Writing Service of a Professional Level

Any academic writer who wishes to join our team of professional writers must possess all the following qualities:

 

To write an exemplary academic paper, you must have good critical thinking skills, possess the proper knowledge of the discipline, and be knowledgeable about applying an academic writing style.

As such we have a rigorous recruitment process. We only collaborate with professional academic writers. We believe in offering the highest quality academic writing services. Our writers pass various grammar and academic writing tests. They have to provide documents about their personal information and credentials to prove their level of expertise.

As a result, our clients receive papers that are thoroughly-researched, properly cited, and written within academic standards. We are proud that any academic writer from our writer's team can complete the paper at a high standard.

We work with the student’s budget because we know that students are usually on a budget majority of the time. We do not compromise on quality because of low prices. On the contrary, we love to foster a good relationship with our clients. That is why we charge our clients reasonable prices, and we are willing to negotiate and work with their budget.

It may be quite disturbing to decide whether to hire an academic writing company. We care about our client’s privacy and confidentiality. We never disclose your information to third parties. We never publish your paper online. You can use our academic writing service without any fear or anxiety.

Many students struggle with writing academic papers. Some barely have time to do their assignments because of their job and family responsibilities. Others have difficulty applying critical thinking skills or meeting time or assignment requirements. Whatever the reason is, you can always have time to do the things you love and other important things. All you need is a reliable and quality academic writing service. Unfortunately, even if you strongly desire to write the paper yourself, you sometimes face unexpected challenges. As we all know, life is unpredictable! Your teacher may be unconcerned about helping students and may not answer your questions. The good news is that there is a way out! You can hire an online academic writer to help you with your assignments. All you need to do is stipulate your paper requirements in the order form, and you can spend your time as you like.

Our Mission

Our company commits towards delivering high-quality custom papers to our clients. We seek to offer reliable essay writing services to our customers in various subject areas. Our customers are very valuable to us. As such, we commit to ensuring that they derive the utmost satisfaction from the essays we deliver. We have a mission to promote our clients' educational and professional lives by providing high-quality essays for their use. We also have a mission to offer a convenient essay writing system where our customers can easily order and pay for the services. We value quality and professionalism in our company.

Get professional help from our brilliant, skilled, and experienced essay writers

We write papers on any subject area, and we also write various types of papers for various purposes. We have a team of able writers who are eager to help our customers with writing services of exceptional quality. We offer custom writing services for customers across the globe and charge affordable prices for our services. We are the best essay writing company offering personalized services to all our customers. We ensure our customers receive maximum satisfaction from the essays we deliver. Our website is the place to be if you are seeking high-quality essays.

By using our academic writing service, we match your paper subject with a writer with a degree in the subject. The writer is able to apply their skills, knowledge, and expertise to the paper. You receive an original, unique, well-research paper, properly cited and formatted. As such, you are assured of a high-quality paper.

Academic Writing Help From Professionals

Truth be told, writing assignments can be stressful and difficult for any student. There is no shame in getting academic writing help. When you search the term “get academic writing help” there are numerous sites that pop up on the results and our website is among them. So, why is it a great idea to choose us?

During your course, your instructor will assign various types of homework. Our academic writers can prepare essays, presentations, speeches, case studies, research papers, dissertations, thesis papers, and more. Our writer’s department is capable of tackling any assignment of any complexity easily. All you need is to give us detailed instructions to help our experts understand the task.After doing so, you can rest assured that everything is in control, and we will deliver a paper of unmatchable quality.

Expert Assignment Help for College/University Students

Are you a college or university student pursuing your Bachelor’s , Masters, PhD, or Doctorate degree? Sometimes juggling schoolwork with work, family and hobbies can seem like a daunting task. You have to sacrifice one or the other. The sole purpose of our website is to alleviate your academic burdens. We ensure that you do not fail in your classes and you get good grades consistently. We understand that there is a need for academic help.

We acknowledge that our clients are not dumb or lazy but only need academic life need help in order to live a balanced life and make ends meet. We make it our core priority to ensure that all assignments are done and submitted before the stipulated deadlines. All our writers are graduates. They are competent in handling the clients’ assignments. We step in to help you with any and all of your assignments. Our assignment help service ensures that you never miss a grade or deadline.

Proceed to order page

Online Academic Help With Different Subjects

Literature

Students barely have time to read. We got you! Have your literature essay or book review written without having the hassle of reading the book. You can get your literature paper custom-written for you by our literature specialists.

Finance

Do you struggle with finance? No need to torture yourself if finance is not your cup of tea. You can order your finance paper from our academic writing service and get 100% original work from competent finance experts.

Computer science

Computer science is a tough subject. Fortunately, our computer science experts are up to the match. No need to stress and have sleepless nights. Our academic writers will tackle all your computer science assignments and deliver them on time. Let us handle all your python, java, ruby, JavaScript, php , C+ assignments!

Psychology

While psychology may be an interesting subject, you may lack sufficient time to handle your assignments. Don’t despair; by using our academic writing service, you can be assured of perfect grades. Moreover, your grades will be consistent.

Engineering

Engineering is quite a demanding subject. Students face a lot of pressure and barely have enough time to do what they love to do. Our academic writing service got you covered! Our engineering specialists follow the paper instructions and ensure timely delivery of the paper.

Nursing

In the nursing course, you may have difficulties with literature reviews, annotated bibliographies, critical essays, and other assignments. Our nursing assignment writers will offer you professional nursing paper help at low prices.

Sociology

Truth be told, sociology papers can be quite exhausting. Our academic writing service relieves you of fatigue, pressure, and stress. You can relax and have peace of mind as our academic writers handle your sociology assignment.

Business

We take pride in having some of the best business writers in the industry. Our business writers have a lot of experience in the field. They are reliable, and you can be assured of a high-grade paper. They are able to handle business papers of any subject, length, deadline, and difficulty!

Statistics

We boast of having some of the most experienced statistics experts in the industry. Our statistics experts have diverse skills, expertise, and knowledge to handle any kind of assignment. They have access to all kinds of software to get your assignment done.

Law

Writing a law essay may prove to be an insurmountable obstacle especially when you need to know the peculiarities of the legislative framework. Take advantage of our top-notch law specialists and get superb grades and 100% satisfaction.

Affordable prices

HIGH SCHOOL
from

$10 page

COLLEGE
from

$13 page

UNIVERSITY
from

$14 page

Our prices depend on the urgency of your assignment, your academic level, the course subject, and the length of the assignment. Basically, more complex assignments will cost more than simpler ones. The level of expertise is also a major determinant of the price of your assignment.

Calculate price

Cheap essay writing service

If you need professional help with completing any kind of homework, is the right place to get it. Whether you are looking for essay, coursework, research, or term paper help, or with any other assignments, it is no problem for us. At our cheap essay writing service, you can be sure to get credible academic aid for a reasonable price, as the name of our website suggests. For years, we have been providing online custom writing assistance to students from countries all over the world, including the US, the UK, Australia, Canada, Italy, New Zealand, China, and Japan.

Our cheap essay writing service has already gained a positive reputation in this business field. Understandably so, since all custom papers produced by our academic writers are individually crafted from scratch and written according to all your instructions and requirements. We offer APA, MLA, or a Chicago style paper in almost 70 disciplines. Here, you can get quality custom essays, as well as a dissertation, a research paper, or term papers for sale. Any paper will be written on time for a cheap price.

Using our cheap essay writing help is beneficial not only because of its easy access and low cost, but because of how helpful it can be to your studies. Buy custom written papers online from our academic company and we won't disappoint you with our high quality of university, college, and high school papers. Although our writing service is one of the cheapest you can find, we have been in the business long enough to learn how to maintain a balance between quality, wages, and profit. Whenever you need help with your assignment, we will be happy to assist you.

Proceed to order page

Cheap paper writing service provides high-quality essays for affordable prices

It might seem impossible to you that all custom-written essays, research papers, speeches, book reviews, and other custom task completed by our writers are both of high quality and cheap. It is surprising, but we do have some tricks to lower prices without hindering quality.

To start using our services, it’s enough to place a request like “I need a writer to do my assignment” or “Please, write an essay for me.” We have a convenient order form, which you can complete within minutes and pay for the order via a secure payment system. The support team will view it after the order form and payment is complete and then they will find an academic writer who matches your order description perfectly. Once you submit your instructions, while your order is in progress and even after its completion, our support team will monitor it to provide you with timely assistance.

Affordable essay writing service: get custom papers created by academic experts

Hiring good writers is one of the key points in providing high-quality services. That’s why we have entry tests for all applicants who want to work for us. We try to make sure all writers working for us are professionals, so when you purchase custom-written papers, they are of high quality and non-plagiarized.

Our cheap essay writing service employs only writers who have outstanding writing skills. The quality of all custom papers written by our team is important to us; that is why we are so attentive to the application process and employ only those writers who can produce great essays and other kinds of written assignments. All our writers are graduates. They are competent in handling the clients’ assignments. We step in to help you with any and all of your assignments. Our assignment help service ensures that you never miss a grade or deadline.

Plagiarism-free affordable papers

All our cheap essays are customized to meet your requirements and written from scratch. Our writers have a lot of experience with academic papers and know how to write them without plagiarism. Moreover, at our academic service, we have our own plagiarism-detection software which is designed to find similarities between completed papers and online sources. You can be sure that our custom-written papers are original and properly cited.

Our essay writing service has a 0% plagiarism tolerance. We are well aware of the dangers of plagiarism. Plagiarism is academic suicide. Our essay writing service ensures that all papers are original. We do not sell pre-written papers. All papers are written from scratch as per the instructions. We pass our papers through powerful anti-plagiarism software such as SafeAssign and TurnItIn.

Money-back guarantee

Our cheap essay writing service tries to always be at its best performance level, so each customer who pays money for paper writing can be sure that he or she will get what is wanted. On the off chance that you don’t like your order, you can request a refund and we will return the money according to our money-back guarantee.

There can be a number of reasons why you might not like your order. If we honestly don’t meet your expectations, we will issue a refund. You can also request a free revision, if there are only slight inconsistencies in your order. Your writer will make the necessary amendments free of charge. You can find out more information by visiting our revision policy and money-back guarantee pages, or by contacting our support team via online chat or phone.

On-time Delivery

We know how important any deadline is to you; that’s why everyone in our company has their tasks and perform them promptly to provide you with the required assistance on time. We even have an urgent delivery option for short essays, term papers, or research papers needed within 8 to 24 hours.

We appreciate that you have chosen our cheap essay service, and will provide you with high-quality and low-cost custom essays, research papers, term papers, speeches, book reports, and other academic assignments for sale. We beat all deadlines. We can also handle urgent orders with deadlines as short as 1 hour. Our urgent paper writing service does not compromise on quality due to the short deadline. On the contrary, our essay writers have a lot of experience which comes in handy in such situations.

24/7 support

We provide affordable writing services for students around the world. That’s why we work without a break to help you at any time, wherever you are located. Contact us for cheap writing assistance. Our impeccable customer support team will answer all your questions and help you out with any issues.

Proceed to order page
Place your order
(550 words)

Approximate price: $22

Calculate the price of your order

550 words
We'll send you the first draft for approval by September 11, 2018 at 10:52 AM
Total price:
$26
The price is based on these factors:
Academic level
Number of pages
Urgency
Basic features
  • Free title page and bibliography
  • Unlimited revisions
  • Plagiarism-free guarantee
  • Money-back guarantee
  • 24/7 support
On-demand options
  • Writer’s samples
  • Part-by-part delivery
  • Overnight delivery
  • Copies of used sources
  • Expert Proofreading
Paper format
  • 275 words per page
  • 12 pt Arial/Times New Roman
  • Double line spacing
  • Any citation style (APA, MLA, Chicago/Turabian, Harvard)

Our guarantees

Delivering a high-quality product at a reasonable price is not enough anymore.
That’s why we have developed 5 beneficial guarantees that will make your experience with our service enjoyable, easy, and safe.

Money-back guarantee

You have to be 100% sure of the quality of your product to give a money-back guarantee. This describes us perfectly. Make sure that this guarantee is totally transparent.

Read more

Zero-plagiarism guarantee

Each paper is composed from scratch, according to your instructions. It is then checked by our plagiarism-detection software. There is no gap where plagiarism could squeeze in.

Read more

Free-revision policy

Thanks to our free revisions, there is no way for you to be unsatisfied. We will work on your paper until you are completely happy with the result.

Read more

Privacy policy

Your email is safe, as we store it according to international data protection rules. Your bank details are secure, as we use only reliable payment systems.

Read more

Fair-cooperation guarantee

By sending us your money, you buy the service we provide. Check out our terms and conditions if you prefer business talks to be laid out in official language.

Read more
error: Content is protected !!
Open chat
1
Need assignment help? You can contact our live agent via WhatsApp using +1 718 717 2861

Feel free to ask questions, clarifications, or discounts available when placing an order.

Order your essay today and save 30% with the discount code HACK